MIAMI LUXHomes

Bay Harbor Islands Homes for Sale under $5M

158 listings

Live MLS inventory in Bay Harbor Islands, updated continuously.

10201 E Bay Harbor Dr # 507, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,745,000
4 bd · 4 ba · 2,105 sqft
10201 E Bay Harbor Dr # 507, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Sereno
1125 97th St # 202, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,725,550
4 bd · 4 ba · 2,869 sqft
1125 97th St # 202, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
MILA BAY HARBOR
1160 101th St # 201, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,725,000
4 bd · 5 ba · 2,864 sqft
1160 101th St # 201, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
ALMA BAY HARBOR
9221 E BAY HARBOR DRIVE # 810, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,695,000
2 bd · 3 ba · 1,851 sqft
9221 E BAY HARBOR DRIVE # 810, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
LA BAIA BAY HARBOR ISLAND
9201 E Bay Harbor Dr # 804, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,695,000
2 bd · 3 ba · 1,851 sqft
9201 E Bay Harbor Dr # 804, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
LA BAIA
1176 97th ST # 501, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,685,000
2 bd · 3 ba · 1,849 sqft
1176 97th ST # 501, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
The Well
9201 E Bay Harbor Dr # 710, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,675,000
2 bd · 3 ba · 1,851 sqft
9201 E Bay Harbor Dr # 710, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
LA BAIA
1135 103 St # 202, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,599,000
2 bd · 3 ba · 1,889 sqft
1135 103 St # 202, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Onda Residences
9201 E Bay Harbor Drive # 502, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,595,000
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,068 sqft
9201 E Bay Harbor Drive # 502, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
LA BAIA BAY HARBOR ISLAND
Listing
$2,490,000
4 bd · 4 ba · 2,620 sqft
Kai
1135 103rd St # 203, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,450,000
3 bd · 4 ba · 2,333 sqft
1135 103rd St # 203, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Onda Residences
1125 97th St # 402, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,350,000
3 bd · 4 ba · 2,447 sqft
1125 97th St # 402, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
MILA BAY HARBOR
9400 W Bay Harbor Dr # 101, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,250,000
4 bd · 5 ba · 2,483 sqft
9400 W Bay Harbor Dr # 101, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
RIVER BAY HARBOR
9201 E Bay Harbor Dr # 604, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,250,000
2 bd · 3 ba · 1,861 sqft
9201 E Bay Harbor Dr # 604, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
LA BAIA SOUTH
9400 W Bay Harbor Drive # 503, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,250,000
3 bd · 3.5 ba · 2,556 sqft
9400 W Bay Harbor Drive # 503, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Riva Bay Harbor Cond
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 7G-S, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,199,000New
3 bd · 3 ba · 1,882 sqft
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 7G-S, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Kai at Bay Harbor
9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 401, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,100,000New
3 bd · 4 ba ·
9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 401, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Alana Bay Harbor
9221 E BAY HARBOR DRIVE # 409, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$2,100,000
2 bd · 3 ba · 1,327 sqft
9221 E BAY HARBOR DRIVE # 409, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
LA BAIA BAY HARBOR ISLAND
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 7H-S, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$1,999,999New
3 bd · 3 ba · 1,834 sqft
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 7H-S, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Kai at Bay Harbor
1125 97th St # 502, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$1,999,000
2 bd · 3 ba · 2,117 sqft
1125 97th St # 502, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
MILA BAY HARBOR
9900 W Bay Harbor Dr # 704, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$1,995,000
2 bd · 3 ba ·
9900 W Bay Harbor Dr # 704, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
9900 West
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 3G-N, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$1,990,000
3 bd · 3 ba · 1,882 sqft
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 3G-N, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
KAI AT BAY HARBOR
1150 101st St # 702, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$1,950,000New
4 bd · 3 ba · 1,972 sqft
1150 101st St # 702, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
One Bay Harbor
1135 103rd # 307, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
$1,900,000
2 bd · 3 ba ·
1135 103rd # 307, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Onda Residences

Homes for Sale under $5M in Bay Harbor Islands — A Local's Guide

Bay Harbor Islands is the low-rise town on two islands in Biscayne Bay, a bridge away from Bal Harbour Shops. Height-capped streets mix mid-century co-ops with South Florida's densest wave of boutique bayfront new construction, much of it with private dockage, and the K-8 school is a genuine draw.

Capping the search at $5.0M turns the Bay Harbor Islands market into a value hunt — and value here hides in specific pockets: an older building with fees that undersell its location, a property type the market overlooks, a block one street off the prime grid. Known for boutique bayfront buildings and an A-rated school, a bridge from Bal Harbour, Bay Harbor Islands always has a below-the-radar corner; this page keeps every listing under the cap in one view so it can't hide.

Bay Harbor Islands Market Snapshot

128
Homes sold, last 12 months
$803K
Median sale price
124 days
Median time on market

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I actually buy in Bay Harbor Islands under $5.0M?

The honest inventory is on this page, updated continuously — and the mix shifts month to month. As a rule, condos stretch a capped budget furthest, townhomes buy space, and houses under a cap trade fastest. We'll tell you plainly which listings are priced low for a reason.

Are there hidden costs beyond the price in Bay Harbor Islands?

Budget association fees on condos and townhomes, insurance that varies with roof age and flood zone, and Florida's closing costs of roughly two to three percent for buyers. We produce a true monthly-cost sheet for any listing before you offer, so the cap holds after closing too.

How do I tour a home in Bay Harbor Islands?

Every listing on this page has an inquiry form that reaches the broker directly — or call +1 786-370-8570. We arrange private showings around your schedule, including video tours for out-of-town buyers, and there is never an obligation.

Discover Your Perfect Home

Select Property Type
Bedroom Size Homes in Bay Harbor Islands
Homes by Price in Bay Harbor Islands
Lifestyle & New in Bay Harbor Islands
Rentals in Bay Harbor Islands
Homes Nearby Bay Harbor Islands: Neighborhoods
Homes Nearby Bay Harbor Islands: Cities
Homes Nearby Bay Harbor Islands: ZIP Codes